Skip to content
Topos Uranos

Summary

This lesson poses the third ancient problem that Calculus I left open: the area of a figure bounded by curves. Since that area is not yet defined, it sets down three requirements that any reasonable definition must meet (a rectangle measures the product of its sides, a figure contained in another has no more area than it, and a figure decomposed into two pieces that do not overlap measures the sum of the pieces) and proves that these requirements suffice to determine some areas: if the figure has an area that meets them, that area can only be one number. With Archimedes’ method of exhaustion, the sum of a geometric progression and the limit of the geometric sequence, it obtains the quadrature of the parabola: the region bounded by a parabola and one of its chords measures four thirds of the inscribed triangle. With inscribed and circumscribed rectangles on equal subintervals of the interval, and with the sums of the squares and of the cubes, it obtains the areas under xx, x2x^2 and x3x^3 on [0,b]\icc{0}{b}, and with the standard limit of the exponential, the area under exe^x. In every case, the difference between the sum from above and the sum from below tends to zero, and this leaves a single possible number: it is the idea that the lesson that follows will turn into the definition of the integral.

Learning objectives

  1. Explain why the area of a curved figure is not yet defined, and state the requirements that any definition of area must meet.
  2. Reproduce Archimedes’ quadrature of the parabola with the sum of a geometric progression and the limit of the geometric sequence.
  3. Compute lower and upper sums of rectangles, with equal subintervals or with a chosen division, and obtain their limits with the sums of powers and the standard limits.
  4. Explain why a difference that tends to zero between the sums from above and from below leaves a single possible value for the area.

An area not yet defined

Of the three ancient problems that Calculus I went through, the course solved two with limits; the third, the area of a curved figure, was left for this course, as the lesson on the final review of Calculus I recalled. For a polygon, elementary geometry gives the area without limits: a rectangle measures the base times the height, a triangle half the base times the height, and every polygon decomposes into triangles. A figure bounded by an arc of a curve does not decompose in this way into a finite number of rectilinear pieces, and elementary geometry does not say what number its area is; it does not even say that it has one. The lesson on angles and their measure admitted as a fact, without proof, that regions bounded by line segments and arcs of circles have an area, and announced that those areas are defined with limits in this course.

Before defining, it is worth deciding what is required. A definition of area that did not give a rectangle the product of its sides, or that gave a figure more area than another figure containing it, would not deserve that name. Here, a figure is a bounded region of the plane enclosed by line segments and by arcs of graphs of continuous functions, like all those in this lesson.

Requirements for area. An area assignment associates with certain figures a number greater than or equal to 00, their area, with the three properties below.
  1. Rectangle: a rectangle with sides parallel to the axes, with base p≥0p \geq 0 and height q≥0q \geq 0, has area pqpq; if one of the sides is zero, the rectangle is a line segment, and its area is 00.
  2. Monotonicity: if a figure is contained in another and both have an area, the area of the first is not greater than that of the second.
  3. Additivity: if a figure is the union of two figures with area that do not overlap, that is, that have in common only points of their boundaries, then it has an area, and its area is the sum of the areas of the two.

By induction on the number of pieces, additivity holds for the union of any finite number of figures with area that pairwise do not overlap. The areas of elementary geometry meet the three requirements, and they are admitted for polygons; those that this lesson will use are the area of the triangle and that of the trapezoid with two vertical sides of lengths pp and qq a distance ww apart, which decomposes into a rectangle and a triangle and measures w(p+q)2\frac{w(p + q)}{2}. The area of no curved figure is admitted.

The question of the lesson is therefore conditional: if a curved figure has an area that meets the requirements, what number can it be? For many figures only one number is possible, and the requirements suffice to find it. The lesson on the Riemann integral will reverse the path: it will define the area under a graph as that number, when it exists. The instrument for passing from the inequalities to a number is the lemma below.

LemmaA number squeezed between two sequences

Let (Ln)(L_n) and (Un)(U_n) be two sequences and AA a number such that Ln≤A≤UnL_n \leq A \leq U_n for every natural number nn. If Un−Ln→0U_n - L_n \to 0, then Ln→AL_n \to A and Un→AU_n \to A, and no other number satisfies the same inequalities. If Ln→LL_n \to L and Un→LU_n \to L, then A=LA = L. If the distance between the bounds tends to zero, only one number fits between them; if the bounds have a common limit, that number is the limit.

Proof

  1. 0≤A−Ln≤Un−Ln→A−Ln→0→Ln→A0 \leq A - L_n \leq U_n - L_n \rightarrow A - L_n \to 0 \rightarrow \resaltar{L_n \to A}

    The distance from AA to the lower bound does not exceed the distance between the bounds. By the squeeze theorem, as contained in the theorem according to which the limit theorems hold for sequences, from the lesson on sequences and their limit, with the zero sequence and the sequence (Un−Ln)(U_n - L_n) as bounds, A−Ln→0A - L_n \to 0, and by the algebra of limits, Ln→AL_n \to A. In the same way, from 0≤Un−A≤Un−Ln0 \leq U_n - A \leq U_n - L_n one obtains Un→AU_n \to A.

  2. Ln→A∧Ln→A′→A′=AL_n \to A \wedge L_n \to A' \rightarrow \resaltar{A' = A}

    If another number A′A' satisfies Ln≤A′≤UnL_n \leq A' \leq U_n for every nn, the preceding move also gives Ln→A′L_n \to A', and by the uniqueness of the limit, from the same theorem, A′=AA' = A.

  3. Ln≤A≤Un→L≤A≤L→A=LL_n \leq A \leq U_n \rightarrow L \leq A \leq L \rightarrow \resaltar{A = L}

    If Ln→LL_n \to L and Un→LU_n \to L, the preservation of inequalities, from the same theorem, applied to Ln≤AL_n \leq A and to A≤UnA \leq U_n with the constant sequence with general term AA, gives the two inequalities; this argument does not use that the difference tends to 00.