Summary
This lesson opens the third unit of the course, devoted to the definite integral: the number that measures the area under a graph, defined as the number that separates the sums of rectangles from below from the sums from above. It presents the path of the unit, which solves the third of the ancient problems with which Calculus I began, the area of a curved figure, in the same way as the other two: with approximations and their limit. The completeness axiom yields the integral; the uniform continuity of the preceding unit guarantees that every function continuous on a closed and bounded interval has one; and the fundamental theorem of calculus connects it with the indefinite integral of the first unit. It reconstructs the history of these ideas, from Archimedes’ quadrature of the parabola, Cavalieri’s indivisibles, Fermat’s areas under the powers and Wallis’s Arithmetica infinitorum, to Barrow, Cauchy’s Résumé des leçons of 1823, Dirichlet’s function of 1829, the Riemann integral and the Darboux sums of 1875; it formulates the problem that runs through it, that of joining two integrals defined in different ways, and shows with two functions that neither of them contains the other. It ends by pointing out the place of the unit in the course and where the definite integral is used in other courses of the site and in science and technology.
Learning objectives
- Describe the path of the unit and explain what each lesson proves and which result of Calculus I, of Algebra and Geometry or of the earlier units it relies on.
- Explain why the definite integral, defined with sums, and the indefinite integral, defined with derivatives, are distinct notions, and which theorem connects them and under which hypotheses.
- Place the results of the unit in their historical context, from Archimedes to Cauchy, Riemann and Darboux, and distinguish the order in which they were discovered from the order in which they are proved.
- Point out the place of the unit in the course and where the definite integral intervenes in other courses and in scientific and technical applications.
Entry assessment
Before working through the unit, it is advisable to measure the starting point. This self-assessment is not graded: it serves to know where to pause. The first six questions cover, in order, the six content lessons of the unit, one each, and measure a skill (computing a sum of rectangles for a decreasing function, finding the lower and upper sums of a function that is not monotonic, deciding whether a function is integrable, working with additivity and reversed limits, differentiating an integral with variable limits, recognizing a symmetry that gives the value of an integral), not a statement to be recalled; the same skills are measured again at the end, in the synthesis lesson, with other data. The last five check what this unit takes as known from Algebra and Geometry, from Calculus I and from the two preceding units: the sum of the squares, the supremum of a set, the corollary on functions with the same derivative, integration by parts and uniform continuity.
Before starting the unit, measure your starting point. It is a short self-assessment: it is not graded and its result is stored only in your browser.
Question 1The interval is divided into four equal subintervals. What is the upper sum of the function , the sum of the areas of the rectangles that cover the region under its graph?
This is the lower sum: the values at the right endpoints have been taken, as if the function were increasing. For a decreasing function the rectangles with heights lie under the graph.The heights have been added without multiplying them by the width of each subinterval, which is : the upper sum is a sum of areas, not of heights.This is the area of the region, which lies between the lower sum, , and the upper one, ; the question asks for the sum of the rectangles with four subintervals, which exceeds it.The function is decreasing on , so on each subinterval its greatest value is at the left endpoint. With widths , the sum is .Review: The area problem
Question 2Let on and the partition . What are the lower sum and the upper sum ?
The infimum on has been taken to be the smaller of the values at the endpoints, ; but the function is not monotonic on that subinterval and drops to in its interior. The infimum is that of all the values on the subinterval.These are the sums with the values at the left endpoints and at the right ones, which coincide with the lower and the upper sum when the function is increasing on each subinterval, and here it is not so on the first.The number is the integral of on , which lies between the two sums; with a partition of only two subintervals, the lower and the upper sum are far from it.The two subintervals have length . On the infimum of is , attained at the interior point , and the supremum is ; on , the function is increasing, with infimum and supremum . Hence and .Review: The Riemann integral
Question 3Which of these functions, defined on , is integrable on ?
It has a single discontinuity, but it is not bounded, and the integral of the unit is defined only for bounded functions: the upper sum of any partition would be infinite. The theorem on finitely many discontinuities requires the function to be bounded.By the density of the rationals and of the irrationals, on each subinterval the infimum is and the supremum is . The lower sums are therefore those of the function , and the lower integral is the integral of , ; the upper ones equal . The lower and the upper integral do not coincide.Continuity suffices for integrability, but it is not necessary: a bounded function with finitely many discontinuities is integrable, and so is a monotonic function, even if it has infinitely many jumps.The function is bounded by and is continuous at every point except at : by the theorem on bounded functions with finitely many discontinuities, it is integrable. That it oscillates infinitely often near does not matter, because the oscillation is confined to a subinterval of length as small as desired.Review: Integrable functions
Question 4A function integrable on satisfies and . What is ?
This is the integral from to . With the limits reversed, the definition of the integral with reversed limits changes its sign.The sign has been changed only for , and not for the integral of the constant: reversing the limits changes the sign of the whole integral, including that of .The constant has been added instead of its integral. The integral of the constant on an interval of length equals , not .By additivity with respect to the interval, ; by linearity, , because the integral of the constant on is the length of the interval. Reversing the limits changes the sign.Question 5Let for real . What is ?
The factor is missing, the derivative of the upper limit: the integral depends on , which moves with speed , and the chain rule requires it.The differentiation has been carried out only with respect to the upper limit. The lower one also depends on , and its contribution carries a minus sign: with , is the difference between the value of at and its value at .The fundamental theorem of calculus guarantees that is differentiable with , because the integrand is continuous; there is no need to write in terms of known functions in order to differentiate , the difference between the value of at and its value at .The integrand is continuous on the real line, and the limits and are differentiable. By the proposition on the derivative of an integral with variable limits, : each limit contributes the value of the integrand at it times its derivative, the lower one with a minus sign.Question 6What is ?
This is the sum of the integral and its reflection, ; it remains to divide by .This is the average value of the integrand on , obtained by dividing the integral by the length of the interval; the integral is that average value multiplied by .The symmetry that makes an integral vanish is that of an odd function on an interval symmetric about . Here the integrand is positive, and the reflection does not change its sign: it turns it into the complementary fraction.The integrand is continuous on . By the proposition on reflection about the midpoint, with , the integral equals that of ; adding the two, the integrand is , and , the length of the interval.Question 7From earlier unitsWhat is the sum ?
This is only the sum of the squares: that of the terms is missing, which the product also contains.The sum of the products has been written as the product of the sums, which are not equal: with , the sum equals , and that product, .has been added to each square instead of : , not .Since , by the properties of summation the sum splits into that of the squares, , by the proposition on the sum of the squares, and that of the first natural numbers, , by the one on the sum of an arithmetic progression. Factoring out leaves .Question 8From earlier unitsLet and be two nonempty sets of real numbers such that for every in and every in . What can be asserted?
They can be equal: with the set of the numbers and that of the numbers , with natural, the hypothesis holds, and the supremum of and the infimum of equal . A strict inequality between the elements does not pass to the supremum and the infimum.With and the hypothesis holds, and the supremum of is , less than the infimum of . That they coincide is precisely what the unit requires of a function in order to call it integrable.The completeness axiom guarantees the supremum of every nonempty set bounded above, and is bounded above by any element of ; likewise, is bounded below by any element of .Each in is an upper bound of , which is nonempty; by the completeness axiom, has a supremum, and since the supremum is the least of the upper bounds, it is less than or equal to each . Then the supremum of is a lower bound of , and it does not exceed the greatest of them, the infimum of , which exists by the same axiom. This is the argument with which the unit compares the lower integral with the upper one.Review: Number systems: from the natural to the complex numbers
Question 9From earlier unitsTwo functions and , defined on the nonzero reals, satisfy for every , and . What can be asserted?
The corollary on functions with the same derivative requires an interval, and the nonzero reals are not one. With and equal to if and to if , the two derivatives are , , and .On the half-line of the positive numbers the constant is ; on that of the negative numbers it may be another. The difference is constant on each half-line, not on the whole domain.They are differentiable at every point of their domain, and by the theorem that differentiable implies continuous, they are continuous at each one: the corollary applies on each half-line.The half-line of the positive numbers is an interval: by the corollary on functions with the same derivative, there , and gives . On that of the negative numbers, and differ by another constant, which the datum at does not fix.Question 10From earlier unitsWhat is the indefinite integral ?
The sign of the cosine is wrong: the derivative of is . An antiderivative of the sine is , and subtracting it changes its sign.Each factor has been integrated separately; the integral of a product is not the product of the integrals, and the derivative of has a term that is not in the integrand.has been taken as an antiderivative of the cosine; an antiderivative of is .By the integration by parts theorem, with and , one gets , and an antiderivative of is . Differentiating the result recovers .Review: Integration by parts
Question 11From earlier unitsWhich of these , for each , guarantees for all and in with ?
It fails with : the points and are less than apart, and , greater than . Near , the function grows with slope close to .It fails with : the points and are less than apart, and . The root works near , where the function is flat, but not near .On a closed and bounded interval, the Heine-Cantor theorem guarantees a common to all points for every continuous function; here the bound suffices to exhibit it.Since and on one has , from it follows that . The same works on the whole interval: this is the definition of a uniformly continuous function.
Loading the content…
Completed
Sign in to save your progress