Summary
This lesson closes the unit on antiderivatives and integration techniques. It gathers into a single deductive chain what the seven content lessons proved: from the corollary of Calculus I according to which two functions with the same derivative on an interval differ by a constant come the antiderivative, the indefinite integral and the table of basic antiderivatives; the chain rule and the product rule, read backward, give the change of variable and integration by parts; and from these two techniques, together with the trigonometric identities and Bézout’s identity, come the families of integrands that reduce to rational functions, whose antiderivatives are written with rational functions, logarithms and arctangents. It explains how the unit rests on Calculus I and on Algebra and Geometry, and what it leaves to the units that follow: the proof of the fundamental theorem of algebra, to the unit on sequences, and the existence of antiderivatives for every continuous function, to the fundamental theorem of calculus. It ends with an exit assessment, parallel to the entry assessment, and with ten challenges, harder than the problems of the lessons, each of which combines results from several of them.
Learning objectives
- Set out in logical order the results of the unit, indicating which results of Calculus I and of Algebra and Geometry each one depends on and in which proofs the change of variable, the change by the inverse function and the antiderivatives of rational functions are reused.
- Distinguish what the unit admits from what it proves, and recognize the hypotheses of each technique, in particular the interval on which each antiderivative holds.
- Relate the unit to Calculus I, to Algebra and Geometry and to the units on sequences and on the definite integral.
- Solve non-routine problems that combine several techniques, decide on which interval an antiderivative holds and extend it to the whole real line when possible.
What the unit achieved
Calculus I proved the differentiation rules; this unit traveled them backward. The starting point was a single corollary of the mean value theorem: if two functions have the same derivative on an interval, they differ by a constant. Written for two antiderivatives and of the same function on an interval :
If this is so, it suffices to find one antiderivative to know them all, and it suffices to differentiate to check that a function is one. From this follows the method of the whole unit: each technique is a theorem whose proof consists in differentiating the result with a rule of Calculus I, and the proofs cite those rules instead of redoing them. Now, the corollary holds only on an interval; therefore, each antiderivative was given with the interval on which it holds, and on a split domain, with one constant for each interval.
The foundation and the table
The lesson on antiderivatives and the indefinite integral defined the antiderivative of a function on an interval, with the one-sided derivatives at the endpoints that belong to it, and proved with the corollary on functions with the same derivative that two antiderivatives on an interval differ by a constant, that a condition at a point fixes a single antiderivative and that, on a union of disjoint open intervals, there are as many constants as intervals, independent of one another, as on shows. It defined the indefinite integral as the family of antiderivatives on an interval, so that the equals sign between two indefinite integrals is an equality between families, and proved by differentiation linearity and the table of basic antiderivatives: the powers, with the interval corresponding to each exponent, the logarithm, the exponentials, the trigonometric functions and their inverses, and the hyperbolic functions and their inverses. It closed with Darboux’s theorem: the sign function has no antiderivative on the real line, although it has one on each half-line, and no function with a jump or removable discontinuity has an antiderivative on an open interval containing that point. That every continuous function has an antiderivative was not used: it is the fundamental theorem of calculus, from the unit on the definite integral.
The two general techniques
The lesson on integration by change of variable read the chain rule backward: if is an antiderivative of , then is one of , without having to be injective; that theorem justifies writing , and gives the linear change of variable, the antiderivatives with a parameter and the three forms , and . When the substitution is written in the opposite direction, , the theorem on change of variable by the inverse function requires that not vanish on an interval: then is strictly monotonic, its inverse is differentiable and the antiderivative goes back to the original variable. The lesson on integration by parts read the product rule backward, which exchanges one problem for another; repeated, it gave the tabular method, proved by induction, the cyclic integrals and the reduction formulas, among them the one for the powers of . In the cyclic integrals and the reductions, solving for the integral, as the computation suggests, presupposes that the antiderivative exists; since without the fundamental theorem of calculus this is not known, the proof differentiates the candidate function. With the mean value theorem, the lesson also obtained the antiderivative of an inverse function, without assuming that the latter is differentiable.
The families
The four lessons that follow applied the two techniques to families of integrands. The lesson on trigonometric integrals split off, when an exponent is odd, a factor that is, up to sign, the derivative of the other function, and when both are even, lowered the degree with the power-reduction formulas, down to a sum of cosines; it proved the antiderivative of the secant, with one constant on each interval of its domain, the reduction of its powers, the products of powers of the tangent and the secant and, with the product-to-sum formulas, the products of sines and cosines with different frequencies. The lesson on trigonometric and hyperbolic substitutions eliminated the roots , and as cases of the change by the inverse function, choosing the interval of the new variable so that the substitution is invertible and the sign of the root known; it compared the trigonometric version with the hyperbolic one and, by completing the square, reduced every root of a polynomial of degree two with nonzero discriminant to one of the three. The lesson on integration of rational functions proved what Algebra and Geometry had admitted: Bézout’s identity for coprime polynomials and, with it, the existence and uniqueness of the partial fraction decomposition, also with irreducible quadratic factors; it integrated each partial fraction and concluded that every rational function has, on each interval without roots of the denominator, an antiderivative made up of a polynomial, a rational function, logarithms and arctangents, whose rational part the Hermite-Ostrogradsky method gives without knowing the roots of the denominator. Finally, the lesson on integration by rationalization brought other families to that one: the rational functions of sine and cosine, with the tangent half-angle substitution or, if parity allows, with shorter substitutions, and the joining of the antiderivatives of adjacent intervals; the roots of linear fractional functions; the roots of polynomials of degree two, with the three Euler substitutions; and the differential binomials, in Chebyshev’s three cases.
What is admitted, what is proved and what remains
The balance of the unit can be summarized as follows:
- The results of Calculus I are admitted, in particular the differentiation rules, the mean value theorem and its corollaries, Darboux’s theorem and Bolzano’s theorem; those of Algebra and Geometry, such as the polynomial division algorithm and the trigonometric identities; and the fundamental theorem of algebra, which Algebra and Geometry admitted in the lesson on roots of higher-degree polynomials and whose proof is announced for the lesson on subsequences and the Bolzano-Weierstrass theorem.
- All the techniques are proved, each by differentiating its result, together with what Algebra and Geometry had left admitted: Bézout’s identity and the partial fraction decomposition with irreducible quadratic factors.
- Three tools are reused instead of repeating arguments: the change of variable, which proves the formulas of almost all the families; the change by the inverse function, in which every substitution ends; and the corollary on the antiderivatives of rational functions, in which all the rationalizations end.
- What demands more than the derivative is left for later: that every continuous function has an antiderivative, that the definite integral is computed with an antiderivative, and the Wallis integrals and the orthogonality of sines and cosines, in the unit on the definite integral; and that certain antiderivatives, such as those of or those of differential binomials outside Chebyshev’s cases, are not elementary, which is mentioned as a fact from later courses.
The following figure gathers the three segments into a single chain. Each node of the column is a result, numbered according to the logical order and joined by an arc to the earlier links that its proof uses; around it float the supports, that is, the principles and tools to which the chain resorts again and again, each one joined by a solid line to the links that rest on it and by a dotted one to the link where it is established, except those that come from Calculus I or from Algebra and Geometry, which are drawn as rings. Clicking a support highlights all the links that use it, and each link refers to the lesson in which it is proved.
Supports of the chain
- AFunctions with the same derivative. Proved in Calculus I with the mean value theorem: if and are continuous on an interval and differentiable at each interior point of , with at each of them, there exists a number such that for every in . It is the foundation of the unit. Admitted without proof in this unit.
- BDerivatives and continuity. Proved in Calculus I: the differentiation rules for the sum, the product and the quotient, the chain rule, the derivative of the inverse function, the derivatives of the elementary functions and of their inverses, and the local character of the derivative; and, for continuous functions, Bolzano’s theorem and the fact that the image of an interval is an interval. Admitted without proof in this unit.
- CMean value and Darboux. Proved in Calculus I: Lagrange’s mean value theorem; the limit of the derivative, which extends an antiderivative up to an endpoint; Darboux’s theorem, according to which a derivative takes all intermediate values; and the fact that a derivative without zeros on an interval gives a strictly monotonic function. Admitted without proof in this unit.
- DAlgebra and Geometry. Admitted from Algebra and Geometry: the polynomial division algorithm, the fundamental trigonometric identities and the product-to-sum formulas, the bijective restrictions of the trigonometric functions and their inverses, and the hyperbolic functions and their inverses. Admitted without proof in this unit.
- EFundamental theorem of algebra. It is admitted, as in Algebra and Geometry, and will be proved in the unit on sequences: every polynomial of positive degree has a complex root; consequently, every real polynomial is the product of a constant and of linear and irreducible quadratic factors. Admitted without proof in this unit.
- FChange of variable. If is an antiderivative of on an interval and is differentiable on an interval with , then is an antiderivative of on : the tool that proves the formulas of the families. Established in: 6. Integration by change of variable.
- GChange by the inverse. If is differentiable on an interval , with on all of , and is an antiderivative of on , then is an antiderivative of on : the stage in which every substitution ends. Established in: 9. Change of variable by the inverse function.
- HRational antiderivatives. Every rational function has an antiderivative on each interval without roots of its denominator, and there is one made up of a polynomial, a rational function, logarithms and arctangents: the destination of every rationalization. Established in: 26. The antiderivatives of rational functions.
Segment 1 The foundation and the table
- Define the antiderivative on an interval and prove, with the corollary on functions with the same derivative, that two antiderivatives differ by a constant, one for each interval if the domain is split.
- Read the indefinite integral as a family and prove by differentiation linearity and the table of basic antiderivatives.
- Show with Darboux’s theorem that a function with a jump has no antiderivative.
Antiderivatives on an interval. If is an antiderivative of on an interval , that is, if for every in , with the one-sided derivatives at the endpoints that belong to , a function is an antiderivative of on if and only if there exists a number such that for every in ; given in and a number , there is a unique antiderivative with .
Rests on: A (Functions with the same derivative), B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Antiderivatives and the indefinite integral.
Domains that are not intervals. If is the union of open intervals , pairwise disjoint, and at each point of , the functions differentiable on with derivative are those equal to on each , with arbitrary and independent constants; thus carries one constant on each half-line.
Uses: 1. Antiderivatives on an interval. Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Antiderivatives and the indefinite integral.
Linearity of antiderivatives. If and are antiderivatives of and of on an interval , and and are real numbers, is an antiderivative of on ; if and are not both zero, as an equality of families.
Uses: 1. Antiderivatives on an interval. Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Antiderivatives and the indefinite integral.
Basic antiderivatives. On the intervals where they hold, for and , as well as the antiderivatives of , , , , , , , of the hyperbolic functions and of , and , each obtained by reading backward a derivative from Calculus I.
Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Antiderivatives and the indefinite integral.
Functions without an antiderivative. The sign function has no antiderivative on , although it has one on each open half-line; and a function defined on an open interval, with a removable or jump discontinuity at a point of it, has no antiderivative on that interval.
Uses: 1. Antiderivatives on an interval. Rests on: C (Mean value and Darboux). Proved in: Antiderivatives and the indefinite integral.
Segment 2 The two general techniques
- Read the chain rule backward: the direct change of variable, which does not require injectivity, the linear change and the forms , and .
- Change the variable by a function whose derivative has no zeros and go back to the original variable with its inverse.
- Read the product rule backward: integration by parts, the tabular method, the cyclic integrals and the reduction formulas, proved by differentiating the candidate.
- Obtain the antiderivative of an inverse function without assuming it differentiable.
Integration by change of variable. If is an antiderivative of on an interval and is differentiable on an interval with , then is an antiderivative of on : ; is not required to be injective.
Uses: 1. Antiderivatives on an interval. Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Integration by change of variable.
Linear change and antiderivatives with a parameter. If is an antiderivative of on an interval and , then on the interval of those for which lies in ; in particular, for , on and on , with analogous formulas for , and .
Uses: 6. Integration by change of variable, 3. Linearity of antiderivatives, 4. Basic antiderivatives. Rests on: F (Change of variable). Proved in: Integration by change of variable.
Three forms of the change of variable. If is differentiable on an interval : if does not vanish on ; ; and for if is positive on , with no condition if is a nonnegative integer and with without zeros if is an integer less than .
Uses: 6. Integration by change of variable, 4. Basic antiderivatives. Rests on: F (Change of variable), B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Integration by change of variable.
Change of variable by the inverse function. If is differentiable on an interval , with for every in , and , then is strictly monotonic, is an interval and is differentiable on ; and if is an antiderivative of on , then is an antiderivative of on : .
Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity), C (Mean value and Darboux). Proved in: Integration by change of variable.
Integration by parts. If and are differentiable on an interval and is an antiderivative of on , then is an antiderivative of on : ; in particular, has an antiderivative on if and only if does.
Uses: 1. Antiderivatives on an interval. Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Integration by parts.
Tabular method. If is a polynomial of degree at most and are functions defined on an interval , each an antiderivative of the one before it, then on .
Uses: 10. Integration by parts, 3. Linearity of antiderivatives. Proved in: Integration by parts.
Cyclic integrals. If and are not both zero, on , and ; solving for the integral, as two integrations by parts suggest, presupposes that the antiderivative exists, and the proof differentiates the candidate.
Uses: 1. Antiderivatives on an interval. Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Integration by parts.
Reduction formulas. For , if is an antiderivative of on , the function is one of ; and for and , if is an antiderivative of on , the function is one of , so that each has on an antiderivative , with rational without real poles.
Uses: 7. Linear change and antiderivatives with a parameter. Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity). Proved in: Integration by parts.
Antiderivative of the inverse function. If is continuous and strictly monotonic on an interval , and is an antiderivative of on , then is an interval and on , without having to be differentiable.
Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity), C (Mean value and Darboux). Proved in: Integration by parts.
Segment 3 The families
- Integrate the powers and products of trigonometric functions, splitting off a factor that is a derivative or lowering the degree, and the secant with one constant on each interval.
- Eliminate the roots of polynomials of degree two with trigonometric and hyperbolic substitutions, choosing the interval of the new variable.
- Prove Bézout’s identity and the partial fraction decomposition, and conclude that every rational function has an antiderivative on each interval without roots of the denominator.
- Rationalize the rational functions of sine and cosine, the roots of linear fractional functions and of polynomials of degree two, and the differential binomials, and join the antiderivatives of adjacent intervals.
An odd exponent. If and are nonnegative integers and is an antiderivative on of the polynomial , then, on , and .
Uses: 6. Integration by change of variable. Rests on: F (Change of variable), D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Trigonometric integrals.
Linearization of even powers. If and are nonnegative integers and , there exist real numbers such that for every real , and then on .
Uses: 7. Linear change and antiderivatives with a parameter. Rests on: D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Trigonometric integrals.
The secant and its powers. On each interval , with an integer, , with one constant per interval in the domain of the secant; and for , if is an antiderivative of on , the function is one of .
Uses: 2. Domains that are not intervals, 8. Three forms of the change of variable. Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity), D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Trigonometric integrals.
Powers of the tangent and the secant. On each , with and nonnegative integers: if and is an antiderivative on of , then ; and if and is an antiderivative on of , then .
Uses: 6. Integration by change of variable. Rests on: F (Change of variable), D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Trigonometric integrals.
The three trigonometric substitutions. For : on gives ; on the same interval gives ; and gives on and on ; in each case the derivative of the substitution does not vanish and its inverse is the corresponding one.
Rests on: D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Trigonometric and hyperbolic substitutions.
Antiderivatives of the three roots. For : on ; on ; and on and on , with one constant on each.
Uses: 7. Linear change and antiderivatives with a parameter, 9. Change of variable by the inverse function, 17. The secant and its powers, 19. The three trigonometric substitutions. Rests on: G (Change by the inverse), C (Mean value and Darboux). Proved in: Trigonometric and hyperbolic substitutions.
The three hyperbolic substitutions. For : on gives ; and , with , give on and on ; and on gives ; the inverses are the inverse hyperbolic sine, cosine and tangent.
Uses: 4. Basic antiderivatives. Rests on: D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Trigonometric and hyperbolic substitutions.
Completing the square. If and , then for every real ; with , the root of a polynomial of degree two reduces to one of the three roots, according to the signs of and of .
Rests on: D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Trigonometric and hyperbolic substitutions.
Bézout’s identity for polynomials. If and are coprime polynomials, there exist polynomials and such that ; and two real polynomials, not both zero, without common complex roots are coprime.
Rests on: D (Algebra and Geometry), E (Fundamental theorem of algebra). Proved in: Integration of rational functions.
Partial fraction decomposition. If is a real polynomial of degree , a product of linear and irreducible quadratic factors, and is zero or of degree less than , there exist unique polynomials , zero or of degree less than that of , such that at every real number that is not a root of .
Uses: 23. Bézout’s identity for polynomials. Rests on: D (Algebra and Geometry), E (Fundamental theorem of algebra). Proved in: Integration of rational functions.
Antiderivatives of the partial fractions. On each half-line and , and, for , ; and if and , on , , with an analogous formula for the powers of the quadratic factor.
Uses: 4. Basic antiderivatives, 7. Linear change and antiderivatives with a parameter, 8. Three forms of the change of variable, 22. Completing the square. Rests on: F (Change of variable). Proved in: Integration of rational functions.
The antiderivatives of rational functions. If is a rational function and is an interval that contains no roots of , has an antiderivative on , and there is one that is the sum of a polynomial, of a rational function whose denominator vanishes only at the real roots of , of multiples of , one for each real root of , and of multiples of and of , one of each kind for each irreducible quadratic factor.
Uses: 3. Linearity of antiderivatives, 13. Reduction formulas, 24. Partial fraction decomposition, 25. Antiderivatives of the partial fractions. Rests on: D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Integration of rational functions.
Hermite-Ostrogradsky method. If is a real polynomial of degree , is zero or of degree less than , and , there exist unique polynomials and , zero or of degree less than that of and that of , such that ; on each interval without roots of , .
Uses: 23. Bézout’s identity for polynomials, 24. Partial fraction decomposition, 25. Antiderivatives of the partial fractions. Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity), E (Fundamental theorem of algebra). Proved in: Integration of rational functions.
The tangent half-angle substitution. If is a rational function of two variables and is defined on an interval contained in , with an integer, the substitution turns the integrand into the rational function , which has an antiderivative , and is an antiderivative of on .
Uses: 9. Change of variable by the inverse function, 26. The antiderivatives of rational functions. Rests on: G (Change by the inverse), H (Rational antiderivatives), D (Algebra and Geometry). Proved in: Integration by rationalization.
Joining two antiderivatives. If is an open interval, is defined on and continuous at a point of , and and are antiderivatives of on the subintervals of to the left and to the right of , with finite limits and at , the function equal to on the left, at and on the right is an antiderivative of on .
Rests on: B (Derivatives and continuity), C (Mean value and Darboux). Proved in: Integration by rationalization.
Substitutions by parity. If is defined on an interval : when , the substitution rationalizes the integrand on ; when , the substitution ; and when and is contained in an interval , the substitution .
Uses: 6. Integration by change of variable, 9. Change of variable by the inverse function, 26. The antiderivatives of rational functions. Rests on: F (Change of variable), G (Change by the inverse), H (Rational antiderivatives). Proved in: Integration by rationalization.
Root of a linear fractional function. If and is defined and does not vanish on an interval , and is positive if is even, the substitution , with inverse , turns into a rational function of times , and its antiderivative, composed with , is an antiderivative on .
Uses: 9. Change of variable by the inverse function, 26. The antiderivatives of rational functions. Rests on: G (Change by the inverse), H (Rational antiderivatives). Proved in: Integration by rationalization.
The Euler substitutions. If , with and , is positive on an interval , the function is rationalized on by if ; by if and does not contain ; and by if has two real roots and and does not contain .
Uses: 9. Change of variable by the inverse function, 26. The antiderivatives of rational functions. Rests on: G (Change by the inverse), H (Rational antiderivatives). Proved in: Integration by rationalization.
Chebyshev’s three cases. If , and are rational, with , and are nonzero reals and is an interval contained in on which , the function has an antiderivative on , obtained from that of a rational function, if is an integer, if is an integer or if is an integer.
Uses: 6. Integration by change of variable, 31. Root of a linear fractional function. Rests on: F (Change of variable). Proved in: Integration by rationalization.
Toward sequences and the definite integral. The chain stops where the derivative ceases to suffice. The whole unit found antiderivatives and checked them by differentiation, but it never proved that an arbitrary continuous function has an antiderivative: the fundamental theorem of calculus will do so, in the unit on the definite integral, by uniting the indefinite integral of this unit with the Riemann integral, which is defined with sums and their limits. Before that, the unit on sequences will provide the missing tool, uniform continuity, obtained with the Bolzano-Weierstrass theorem, and will prove the fundamental theorem of algebra that this unit admitted. The techniques of the unit will then pass to the definite integral, which is computed with any antiderivative, and to the areas, the volumes, the arc length and the improper integrals of the later units.
Loading the content…
Completed
Sign in to save your progress