Summary
The ratio and root tests compare a series with a geometric one, and for that reason they cannot prove the convergence of any series whose terms are at least a positive multiple of a power of ; in the series of reciprocals of powers, the ratio tends to . This lesson compares the ratio with that of series that converge or diverge more slowly. Kummer’s test gives the common scheme: once a positive sequence has been chosen, an inequality between and makes the sequence decreasing and bounds the partial sums, or makes it increasing and compares the series with that of the . With one obtains Raabe’s test, which measures the distance from the ratio to in multiples of ; with , Bertrand’s; and from the two, Gauss’s, which decides every series whose ratio is a rational function of the index tending to , such as the hypergeometric series. The logarithmic test compares the term with the powers of , and Ermakov’s test compares the integral of a decreasing function with that of its composition with the exponential; with it one proves the scale of the series with iterated logarithms in the denominator. The lesson ends with a reasoned guide for choosing the test.
Learning objectives
- Prove Kummer’s test and deduce from it Raabe’s, with Duhamel’s form, and Bertrand’s, understanding each one as the choice of a comparison sequence.
- Prove Gauss’s test, with the case , and use it to decide the series whose ratio is a rational function of the index tending to .
- Prove the logarithmic test and Ermakov’s test, and with the latter the scale of the series with iterated logarithms in the denominator.
- Choose with reasons the test that decides a series with positive terms, and recognize when a test does not decide.
Comparing the ratios
The lesson on ratio and root tests proved that, if from some index on, with , neither the root nor the ratio proves the convergence of the series, and it announced this lesson: the ratio is compared here with that of the series of reciprocals of powers and with that of others that converge or diverge even more slowly, and not with that of the geometric series. The notation of the earlier lessons is kept: , the sum , the remainder , the series from an index, and the notation , which the lesson on series with positive terms reserves for saying that a series with nonnegative terms converges. Throughout the lesson the terms are positive, so that one can divide by them; if they are positive only from some index on, the proposition on the tail of a series, from the lesson on numerical series and their convergence, allows one to discard the first ones.
Let and be sequences of positive terms and a natural number such that for every . Then for every . Consequently, if converges, also converges; and if diverges, also diverges. If the terms of a series decrease, from each one to the following, in a proportion at least as strong as those of another, the first series stays below a multiple of the second.
Proof
Let . On multiplying the hypothesis by the positive number , the quotient does not grow from one index to the following; by induction on , starting from , it does not exceed its value at .
If converges, by the proposition on linearity and monotonicity of series, from the lesson on numerical series and their convergence, the series of the also converges, and the theorem of the comparison test for series, from the lesson on series with positive terms, with the inequality from on, gives the convergence of . The second statement is the contrapositive of the first.
With , the laws of real exponents, from the lesson on the exponential function and powers with real exponents, give : if from some index on, with , the series converges, because the series of the converges, by the proposition on the series of reciprocals of powers, from the lesson on series with positive terms. Kummer’s test generalizes this idea: instead of fixing the series used for comparison, it weights the terms with a positive sequence that is chosen according to the series.
Loading the content…
Completed
Sign in to save your progress